Nate Bear, Lead Technical Tactician, Monument Traders Alliance
Holy moly.
Earnings season kicks off tomorrow with JPM, WFC, BLK, and C, and while everyone’s trying to guess which way these stocks are gonna move, I’m sitting here getting excited about something completely different.
I think most traders are approaching this all wrong.
They’re positioning BEFORE earnings, buying calls, buying puts, trying to predict outcomes.
That’s insane to me because here’s what they’re missing: the real money isn’t in guessing.
It’s in the mathematical chaos that happens AFTER a stock beats by more than 1.5 times the expected move.
Here’s What Happened With APP (And Why It Matters)
Let me tell you about APP on November 7th, 2024 because this is exactly what I’m looking for this week.
The market was implying a 12% move – that’s what the options were pricing in. The stock moved 46%. That’s nearly four times the expected move.
I grabbed those APP 11/8 $255 calls at 80 cents early in the session.
Sold half for a quick triple-digit gain, held the rest and they hit $5.30. About 600% when the math breaks down that badly.
All in less than an hour!
But here’s the thing – this wasn’t some genius prediction. I had no idea what APP was going to do before earnings.
I was just waiting for the mathematical setup where market makers get caught with their pants down.
The Market Maker Pain Trade (This Is Where It Gets Interesting)
All right, so here’s how this actually works.
When market makers price options before earnings, they’re essentially making a bet on volatility.
They calculate an expected move – in APP’s case, about 12% – and they price those options so that if the stock moves exactly that amount, nobody makes money except them.
They’re selling premium to both call buyers and put buyers, collecting that sweet time decay. It’s a beautiful business model when stocks behave predictably.
But when a stock beats by 1.5 times that expected move?
Holy moly, that’s when everything falls apart for them.
APP opened at $230, hit $257.43 during the session. Think about the market makers who sold those 255 calls.
They probably sold them for pennies, thinking there was almost no chance APP would get there. Suddenly they’re sitting on massive losses and they HAVE to hedge.
They can’t just sit there and hope it comes back down.
They have to buy stock or buy calls to cover their short positions. That creates forced buying pressure that can push the stock even higher.
Here’s the Exact Numbers I’m Watching This Week
So while everyone’s focused on guidance and estimates, I’m watching for these specific thresholds. Here are the implied moves for the big earnings coming up:
NFLX: 7.59% – I need to see this thing move above 11.4% to get excited. Netflix has been all over the place lately, so if they beat big on subscriber numbers, this could really run.
TSM: 5.39% – Watching for 8%+ moves. Semiconductor earnings have been wild this year, and if they give strong AI guidance, market makers could get caught off guard.
AA: 7.98% – Need to see 12%+ to get interested. Alcoa’s a smaller name but when commodities move, they really move.
ASML: 6.27% – Looking for 9.4%+ moves. This one’s interesting because it’s such a key supplier to the chip industry.
WFC: 4.58% – Watching for 6.9%+ moves. Banks have been boring lately, but if they surprise on net interest margin or credit quality, this could work.
These aren’t predictions – these are just the mathematical thresholds where market maker pain starts to kick in.
Most of these will stay within their expected ranges, and that’s fine. I’m not trying to bat 1.000 here.
My Actual Game Plan (Position Sizing Matters)
Here’s what I’m actually going to do. If any of these beat their expected moves by 1.5x, I’ll throw small limit orders at out-of-the-money calls for the following week. Not market orders – limit orders, because the spreads are going to be terrible in the first few minutes.
I’m talking about risking maybe $200-500 per trade, not betting the farm. The beauty of this setup is that when it works, it can pay for a lot of losers.
But you have to size it right because most of these plays expire worthless.
The Real Risk Management Part (This Is Important)
Let me be clear about something – this is speculation, not investing. I’m using money I can afford to lose completely. When I say “small position,” I mean it. This isn’t rent money or retirement savings.
The other thing is timing. These moves happen fast. If you’re not watching the market near the open, you’re probably going to miss the setup entirely.
And if you chase it after the initial move, you’re probably going to get burned.
I think the sweet spot is getting positioned within the first 30 minutes of the market open, taking profits on half when you double your money, and letting the rest ride as a “free” trade.
What Actually Drives These Moves
The thing that gets me excited about this setup is that it’s not really about the fundamentals of the company. It’s about the mathematical mechanics of the options market.
When a stock moves 1.5x its expected move, you’re essentially breaking the model that market makers used to price those options. They have to scramble to hedge their positions, and that creates momentum that can feed on itself.
It’s not guaranteed – nothing in trading is. But it’s a repeatable setup based on market structure, not trying to predict whether a company is going to beat earnings by 2 cents or 3 cents.
Nothing published by Monument Traders Alliance should be considered personalized investment advice. Although our employees may answer your general customer service questions, they are not licensed under securities laws to address your particular investment situation. No communication by our employees to you should be deemed personalized investment advice. We allow the editors of our publications to recommend securities that they own themselves. However, our policy prohibits editors from exiting a personal trade while the recommendation to subscribers is open. In no circumstance may an editor sell a security before subscribers have a fair opportunity to exit. The length of time an editor must wait after subscribers have been advised to exit a play depends on the type of publication. All other employees and agents must wait 24 hours after publication before trading on a recommendation.
Any investments recommended by Monument Traders Alliance should be made only after consulting with your investment advisor and only after reviewing the prospectus or financial statements of the company.
Protected by copyright laws of the United States and international treaties. The information found on this website may only be used pursuant to the membership or subscription agreement and any reproduction, copying or redistribution (electronic or otherwise, including on the world wide web), in whole or in part, is strictly prohibited without the express written permission of Monument Traders Alliance, LLC, 14 West Mount Vernon Place, Baltimore, MD 21201.