Site icon Peter A. Hovis

šŸ‡ŗšŸ‡ø Have we forgotten how to cover a civil debate?

Advertisement
Read in browser

Your Week with AZCentral

A SPOTLIGHT ON THE JOURNALISM YOUR SUBSCRIPTION HELPS BRING TO LIFE.
Fri Oct 4 2024

Bill GoodykoontzĀ |Ā Media Critic

@goodyk

Hey readers,
Iā€™m back. Iā€™m Bill Goodykoontz, the media columnist for The Arizona Republic , and Iā€™m writing the newsletter this week. And I have a question.
Did you watch the vice-presidential debate Tuesday night ? I did. (On the other hand, I get paid to; I donā€™t know if Iā€™d have slogged through it for free.) JD Vance and Tim Walz met. Like every other journalist who writes about this kind of thing, given the stakes, I was ready for a fight.
And didnā€™t really get one.
The debate turned out to be, in the words of seemingly every headline written about it, surprisingly civil . The two candidates complimented each other, noted where they agreed on certain issues (or at least aspects of them) and never resorted to immature, schoolyard name-calling. Instead, they actually talked about issues.
What are we supposed to say about that?
Kidding, kidding. Sort of. This is how debates used to be, after all. But in the Donald Trump era, weā€™re used to fireworks. Which are easier to cover, frankly, if more dispiriting. There was the time CNNā€™s Jake Tapper described a debate between Trump and Joe Biden as ā€œa hot mess inside a dumpster fire inside a train wreck.ā€ More recently, well, there was Trump and Kamala Harrisā€™ September debate, in which Harris predictably baited Trump into losing his temper and barking out nonsense.
Of course, appearances can be deceiving. Vance lied quite a bit and got angry that co-moderators Norah Oā€™Donnell and Margaret Brennan fact-checked him. (They didnā€™t spare Walz; they asked why he had mischaracterized being in Hong Kong during the Tiananmen Square massacre in 1989. He bonked the answer.)
And there was real news. Walz asked Vance flat-out whether Trump lost the 2020 election (Trump continues to lie about it). Vanceā€™s answer was telling. ā€œTim, Iā€™m focused on the future.ā€ Walz called it a ā€œdamning nonanswer.ā€
Thatā€™s about as contentious as it got. Maybe it was a throwback. But maybe it should also be the future.

Opinion: How Fox News, CNN reacted to oddly civil VP debate

Who won the VP debate between JD Vance and Tim Walz? Margaret Brennan and Norah Oā€™Donnell, in an oddly civil contest. How CNN and Fox News reacted.
READ MORE
Advertisement

Opinion: Ted Simonsā€™ Kari Lake interview was best Iā€™ve seen

Ted Simons talked with Kari Lake on ā€œHorizonā€ on Arizona PBS in a fair, if relentless interview. It was a masterful example of pushing back on lies.

READ MORE

Giant nude statue of Donald Trump arrives in Phoenix

The mysterious traveling figure first surfaced in Las Vegas before arriving in Phoenix. It is titled ā€œCrooked and Obscene.ā€

READ MORE

These 10 restaurants could win Top Taco 2024. Vote now

Itā€™s up to you to decide who makes the best taco in metro Phoenix in 2024. Check out the 10 finalists, including Taā€™Carbon, Tacos Chiwas and Xolo.

READ MORE

More AZ schools offering ā€˜culturally relevantā€™ classes

There is a growing number of classes offered by school districts in the Valley that focus specifically on the experiences of African Americans.

READ MORE

How Kris Kristofferson made AZ history in ā€˜Star Is Bornā€™

The audience at ASU Sun Devil Stadium was asked to boo Barbra Streisandā€™s ā€œA Star Is Bornā€ co-star at a concert topped by Peter Frampton and Santana.

READ MORE

Sign up for the news you want

Exclusive newsletters are part of your subscription, donā€™t miss out! Weā€™re always working to add benefits for subscribers like you.
SEE ALL NEWSLETTERSĀ āž”
Advertisement
NewslettersĀ  Ā |Ā  Ā  eNewspaperĀ  Ā |Ā  Ā Crosswords
Follow Us
Problem viewing email? View in browser
Unsubscribe Ā ā€¢ Ā Manage Newsletters Ā ā€¢ Ā Terms of ServiceĀ Ā ā€¢ Ā Privacy Policy/Your California Privacy Rights Ā ā€¢ Ā  Privacy NoticeĀ  ā€¢Ā Ā Do Not Sell My Info/Cookie Policy Ā ā€¢ Ā Feedback
Exit mobile version
Skip to toolbar